By Brent Robillard
Should I buy the 39mm or the 42mm HydroConquest?
I get asked this question… a lot. So, I’m going to attempt an answer. Right here. Right now. By explaining why I would choose the 39mm. I hope it helps.
Oddly, my favourite 42mm watch goes a long way toward demonstrating why I’d buy the 39mm Longines HydroConquest. Bear with me.
When Longines introduced the redesigned HydroConquest in Mexico City back in March, I had both sizes in front of me, along with enough dial and bracelet combinations to keep me occupied for a while. I went through them more than once. My wrist had a preference for the 39 almost immediately. My head took a little longer to come around. After all, I wear a 41mm Omega Seamaster Professional 2531.80 on a regular basis. And if you offered to shrink my 42mm Breitling Aerospace by three millimetres, I’d ask you to kindly put it down.

Advertisement
The Citizen Attesa H800 Full Sapphire Bezel 2.0 Hazy Black in the Metal
Here’s the funny thing. That Breitling measures 48mm from lug tip to lug tip. The 39mm HydroConquest? 48.1mm. Across the top of my wrist, there’s a tenth of a millimetre between them. You could spend a fair bit of time arguing the merits of 39 versus 42 online before realising you and the fellow on the other end might actually like the same fit.
Now, I feel at this juncture that I should invoke some of the wisdom I have gleaned from reading Malcolm Galdwell’s Blink: Sometimes thinking less leads to better decisions, but knowing when to trust your instincts is the real skill. The paraphrasing is mine.
I will now, ironically, go about the business thinking of more and doing it aloud. Forgive me, we will get there. Eventually.

Two sizes on a 6¾-inch wrist
I’m six foot three, with a 6¾-inch wrist. Fairly ordinary circumference, I’d say, though mine is broader and flatter across the top than you might guess from a tape measure. Someone with a rounder wrist could borrow my tape, get precisely the same reading, and have the lugs land in a different spot. Most of my collection falls between 38mm and 43mm. Which end of that range I reach for has a lot to do with the shape of the case and, frankly, what I feel like wearing that day—the activity at hand.
The HydroConquest makes for a particularly good side-by-side because Longines kept both versions 11.7mm thick. Moving up to the 42 buys you more watch across the wrist without adding anything under a shirt cuff. Where I notice the extra size is at the ends of the lugs. The span goes from 48.1mm to 51.2mm. My flat wrist gives those longer lugs somewhere to go, and I quite like the way the 42 fills the available space. Some days you want to look down and see a big dive watch. The 42 scratches that itch rather nicely.


Then again, the Longines I’ve actually acquired for my own collection are the 39mm Legend Diver and the Spirit Zulu Time 1925, also 39mm. You might reasonably see a pattern here. Though at the very same Mexico City presentation, the watch giving the HydroConquest the most competition for my affection was the 42mm Legend Diver 59. Apparently even my patterns have exceptions.

What would I ask of a HydroConquest?
For years, when someone has asked me to recommend a good Swiss diver, the HydroConquest has been one of my first suggestions. When I compared it with the Tudor Black Bay, I had a particular buyer in mind. Someone who’d like to own one good watch and get on with wearing it. Put my own money on the counter and, for the purposes of this exercise, that’s me.
I’d happily take either size out in the kayak. Both give me 300 metres of water resistance and the same ceramic timing bezel, which has a particularly satisfying click on this generation. Both run on the automatic calibre L888.5 with up to 72 hours of power reserve. I’m getting the full dive watch whichever way I go. So I start thinking about the other things I do in the course of a week.
A hike, a few hours working around the house or out in the yard, a beer with friends. I can picture the either the 39 or the 42 on my wrist for any of it. Then there’s the occasional evening when I have to put on a suit and tie. I do have to dress the part from time to time, and on those occasions I’d sooner the first thing you noticed about me was something other than the size of my watch. With the 39, I could put on a clean shirt, do up the cuff, and head out wearing the same watch I’d had on all afternoon. That, more than the circumference of my wrist, is what settles it for me.
Put simply: watch dimensions + wrist size and shape + lifestyle = decision.

I’d still try it on both bracelets
Just to throw a wrench into all of this, the H-link offered on several models tapers significantly, and on the 39 that taper can make the watch feel a little finer, less “tooly.” Which is a funny thing to say about a steel diver with crown guards and a big, toothy bezel, but there you are. Put it on the fine mesh and, despite the aesthetic, I get a very different impression. I like seeing that little expanse of woven steel on either side of the case. It feels a little more substantial. It’s comfortable, but it also keeps its form. The watch has plenty of presence there, even in the smaller size.
Longines did something clever with the mesh, too. You remove links to size it, so you don’t wind up with a spare length of bracelet doubled back under the clasp. It lies flatter as a result. Both bracelets offer micro-adjustment, and at the Canadian launch the HydroConquest was $2,900 CAD on the H-link or $3,100 CAD on mesh. Of course, each model comes a prescribed version of the bracelet… so you have to cozy up to your AD, if you want the other (or both).

Which leaves the colour. In Mexico City, I was all about the black dial with the slate-grey bezel on mesh. Looking back at the photographs, I can see exactly why. Trouble is, the blue on blue has really grown on me since then. And, well, black on black is so classic.
I’ve got the size nailed down. And I feel good about that decision. It might take me another six months to pick the colourway, but I’ll get there. Decisions, decisions. Malcolm Gladwell would tell me that my choice is already made, of course. Oh, Malcolm.



A Tale of Two Rolex Pepsis: 5 Digits or 6?
Advertisement
Check out The Ultimate Watch Buying Guide
About the author
Brent Robillard is a writer, educator, craftsman, and watch enthusiast. He is the author of four novels. You can follow him on Instagram.
Off The Cuff articles are full-length, hands-on reviews of the watch in question and represent the opinion of the author only. All photos are original, unless specified otherwise. If you would like to have your watch reviewed on this site, contact us here.
Please understand that using any links to products on this site might result in us making money.



One thought on “Longines HydroConquest 39mm vs 42mm: Why I’d Buy the 39”