By Brent Robillard
The Rolex GMT-Master II 16710 T vs the 126710BLRO
Three per cent. I keep coming back to that number.
Recently, I asked my Instagram followers which era of Rolex they preferred: four, five, or six digits. Five digits won, narrowly beating four. Six digits collected just 3% of the vote. Apparently, I had gathered a crowd quite happy to leave several decades of development on the table.
I should probably admit that I was among them.
Back in October, while photographing watches at Kaplans in Stockholm, I had the opportunity to handle several Rolexes from all three eras. Among them were two Pepsi GMT-Master IIs: a 16710 T and a 126710BLRO. Trying them side by side helped put some shape to a preference I’ve had for a while. Given the choice, I lean toward five digits. And the more I think about why, the less useful the spec sheet becomes.

Advertisement
The argument against 4 digits
There’s plenty about a four-digit Submariner or Explorer that gets me going. The proportions, the patina, the evidence of a life before mine. I could happily spend an afternoon photographing one. Wearing it regularly would be another matter. I’d worry about damaging it, and about what that damage might mean for its value. Whether every concern was justified or not, I know myself well enough to recognise that I’d hesitate.
I also want a watch to do its job. If I own a Submariner, Sea-Dweller, or GMT-Master, I want to feel comfortable getting it wet. Certainly swimming, and, with the appropriate watch, perhaps diving. A five-digit reference feels closer to the balance I’m after. Old enough to have some character, recent enough that I can imagine getting on with wearing it. Condition and a proper pressure test would still decide whether an individual watch came swimming, even if the reference number alone wouldn’t get it into the lake.

Advertisement
Two great GMTs
The two GMTs make an interesting pair because so much of the basic proposition remains the same. Both have 40mm steel cases, sapphire crystals with Cyclops magnifiers, a date, and a red-and-blue, bidirectional 24-hour bezel. Both were rated for 100 metres of water resistance. Both let you jump the local hour hand independently while keeping home time on the 24-hour hand. For the travelling I do, either covers the brief comfortably.
The older example, from 2004, houses the automatic calibre 3185. It’s a COSC-certified chronometer with roughly 48 hours of power reserve, worn here on an Oyster bracelet. The newer watch, from 2018, has the calibre 3285 and a Jubilee bracelet. Its reserve stretches to approximately 70 hours, and Rolex specifies accuracy of −2/+2 seconds per day after casing. The Oysterlock clasp adds a 5mm Easylink comfort extension, while ceramic replaces aluminum in the bezel insert.
There’s a perfectly good case for choosing the newer watch. I can make it myself. I just keep looking at the other one.

What is it about the 16710 T?
The 16710 T’s slimmer lugs do a lot of the work. So do the smaller crown and less obtrusive crown guards. Together, they give the case a shape I prefer on my wrist. The two watches may share a nominal diameter, but 40mm tells you very little about those relationships. You have to put them on.
Then there’s the bezel. I prefer the smaller numerals on the five-digit watch and the appearance of aluminum. I love what can happen to its colour over time. That gradual fading is part of the appeal, which puts me in the slightly awkward position of admiring a material for doing something its successor was developed to resist.
I’m less categorical about the dial. The larger luminous plots and thicker hands of the 126710BLRO look good to me, and their legibility makes sense. I understand the attraction. Even so, the finer hands and smaller markers of the 16710 T leave more room around everything. To my eye, that lighter treatment feels more timeless. Someone else will look at exactly the same pair and find the older dial a little underfed. Fair enough.

Advertisement
Forget about the specs
What struck me afterwards was how little the mechanical improvements had influenced my preference. Seventy hours of reserve is useful. So is an easy bracelet extension when your wrist swells. Greater resistance to scratches is useful, too. I appreciate all of it. Yet none of those things persuaded me to give up the case, bezel, and dial I preferred.
Even accuracy has a point beyond which my interest starts to fade. The 3185 was already a chronometer. Assuming it’s healthy and properly serviced, I’m unlikely to spend much time wishing it could shave another second or two from its daily rate. I’ll spend considerably more time looking at its dial.
Perhaps I care less about some of these refinements than I’ve been trained to think I do. A clasp can be more sophisticated and still fail to make the whole watch more appealing to me. Calling it “better” describes one part of the experience. It doesn’t settle which watch I want to wear.
Watch media spend a lot of time on this stuff. The Calibrated Wrist included. A new movement arrives with a longer reserve, a tighter accuracy claim, or a different escapement, and we write about it. Of course we do. There’s something new to explain, and the numbers give us a convenient comparison. Seventy is more than 48. A slimmer lug is a much harder argument to win.
I wonder how much of that discussion reaches someone who simply likes watches without reading about them every day. Do they know the claimed daily rate? Would they notice the extra reserve? Some certainly would. But I suspect plenty arrive at a preference by putting a watch on, looking down, and deciding whether they like what they see. Having tried these two together, I’m not sure my own process is much more complicated.

The problem with my research
Which brings me back to that poll. Before anyone declares modern Rolex finished, there are a few fairly obvious problems with my research. I used photographs of the five-digit watch. My followers probably share some of my tastes. The collectability and perceived value of older references may have played a part, as might frustration with availability and waiting lists for newer ones. I was polling my corner of Instagram, with my thumb quite possibly resting on the scale.
Still. Three per cent?
In a later poll, roughly 85% agreed that they liked modern Rolex and certainly wouldn’t turn one down. So we can probably cancel the funeral. Preferring an older reference leaves plenty of room to enjoy a newer one.

Advertisement
Old vs new
As I thought about the results and read the comments, though, another possibility began to bother me. Perhaps some of what I like about the older watches is simply that time has already had a go at them.
A well-kept watch like this 16710 T appeals to me partly because it has been around. I respond to patina, to the small changes that accumulate through use. I don’t need to know the previous owner or imagine some extraordinary adventure. There was a life before the watch reached my wrist, and I like being able to see evidence of it.
That’s also why fauxtina never quite scratches the same itch. I can enjoy warm lume on a new watch as a colour choice. But an aged-looking finish comes with the watch on day one. Actual wear leaves me wondering what happened along the way.
So what if I could meet both of these Pepsis as they appeared when new? No fading, no accumulated marks, no intervening years to lend one a little extra charm. Would I still reach for the 16710 T?
I suspect I would. The lugs would still be slimmer, the bezel numerals smaller, and the dial a little more restrained. Those preferences seem fairly well established. But I’m less certain that the decision would be as immediate and categorical. Maybe I’ve been giving design all the credit for an attraction that owes something to age.

Final Thoughts
I’d love to hear from the 3% who chose six digits. What settled it for you? The proportions? The bracelet? The pleasure of owning a watch whose wear will be entirely your own? And for those who voted four or five, how close was the decision? Did you hesitate over the newer watch before choosing the older one?
I know which of these two I’d put on first. I’m still working out quite how much that tells me about my taste.
Advertisement
Check out The Ultimate Watch Buying Guide
About the author
Brent Robillard is a writer, educator, craftsman, and watch enthusiast. He is the author of four novels. You can follow him on Instagram.
Other Watchy Bits include op-ed pieces and articles of general interest. We’d love to hear your opinion in the comments section below.
Please understand that using any links to products on this site might result in us making money.





